If this is your first visit, check out the community guide. You will have to Join us or Sign in before you can post.

DLA Evidence In PIP Appeals

keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
My brother is appealing the short length of his PIP award due to his long standing medical conditions . The DWP stated in their submission to the Tribunal that he didn't ask for his DLA evidence to be taken into account when he originally made his phone claim to PIP. However, the telephone operator did not ask him if he wanted his DLA evidence taken into account? In the DWP bundle there is no evidence that he was asked this question. Where does this leave him as far as his appeal is concerned?

Replies

  • CockneyRebelCockneyRebel Posts: 3,874Member, Community champion Brian Blessed
    Hi keira

    Is your brother only appealing the award length ?

    CR
    Be all you can be, make  every day count. Namaste
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    Hi CR,

    No, he is appealing another issue too. However, the statement re the DLA evidence is only cited in their reasons for not giving a longer award and is not mentioned anywhere else in their submission.
  • CockneyRebelCockneyRebel Posts: 3,874Member, Community champion Brian Blessed
    Hi keira

    If your brother has DLA evidence that is fairly recent then it will be a good idea to submit this for his appeal

    CR
    Be all you can be, make  every day count. Namaste
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    Thanks but the DLA evidence is not recent. Also, I didn't realise that DLA evidence was relevant as it is a different benefit with different criteria.



  • CockneyRebelCockneyRebel Posts: 3,874Member, Community champion Brian Blessed
    If the DLA evidence is not recent/relevant then you need to concentrate on showing that he meets the criteria for the challenge. Long term DLA may have been of use as to length of award and likely prospects

    CR
    Be all you can be, make  every day count. Namaste
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    If DLA evidence can help in some cases then they need to advertise this more widely. Not just say someone didn't ask for it to be used when making their phone claim to PIP and then they can't even produce any evidence of this!
  • CockneyRebelCockneyRebel Posts: 3,874Member, Community champion Brian Blessed
    Hi keira

    A recent post by @mikehughescq mentioned the possible benefit but I can't find the post at the moment

    CR
    Be all you can be, make  every day count. Namaste
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    Thanks CR. Hopefully @mikehughescq can give his advice regarding this.
  • MatildaMatilda Posts: 2,366Member Brian Blessed
    The only medical evidence I submitted for my PIP appeal was the DWP doctor's report and my GP's report from 1998 when I first claimed DLA, my PIP appeal Hearing taking place some 19 years later.  The tribunal placed a lot of weight in this old medical evidence; however, I do have a condition that can never improve.  So, old medical evidence is likely to be accepted if at the time you had a condition that cannot get better.
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    @mikehughescq ;

    Could you possibly offer any advice regarding this matter please.
  • mikehughescqmikehughescq Posts: 2,205Member Brian Blessed
    Very simple. In view of the assertion that DLA evidence was not requested you 

    1) Post the evidence to HMCTS and ask for its inclusion in the appeal papers. Don’t tell them what it is. Just write a letter advising that this is further evidence for inclusion. This won’t be refused. It’ll then be up to the tribunal as to what weight they give to that.

    2) Make a separate request headed “Request for a direction” and ask for a judge to direct the DWP to include the PIP 1 as

    a) it ought to be in every set of appeal papers.’
    b) DWP need to evidence their assertion the answer to the DLA questujn was no.

    HOWEVER, it is naive to think that any of the above will automatically tip a PIP decision your way. You need to identify the specific points to be scored and identify the more recent evidence to support that, especially anecdotal examples of daily living and mobility issues.
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    Very simple. In view of the assertion that DLA evidence was not requested you 

    1) Post the evidence to HMCTS and ask for its inclusion in the appeal papers. Don’t tell them what it is. Just write a letter advising that this is further evidence for inclusion. This won’t be refused. It’ll then be up to the tribunal as to what weight they give to that.

    2) Make a separate request headed “Request for a direction” and ask for a judge to direct the DWP to include the PIP 1 as

    a) it ought to be in every set of appeal papers.’
    b) DWP need to evidence their assertion the answer to the DLA questujn was no.

    HOWEVER, it is naive to think that any of the above will automatically tip a PIP decision your way. You need to identify the specific points to be scored and identify the more recent evidence to support that, especially anecdotal examples of daily living and mobility issues.

    Thanks Mike,

    Would it make any difference to the tribunal if the the PIP1 proved that they did/didn't ask my brother if he wanted his DLA evidence used as this is the only reason the DWP have given for not giving him a longer PIP award?



  • mikehughescqmikehughescq Posts: 2,205Member Brian Blessed
    If you can get the DLA evidence into the appeal papers then job done anyway. 
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    If you can get the DLA evidence into the appeal papers then job done anyway. 
    He doesn't have the evidence and it's not recent anyway.

    Just one more thought, he never received his invitation to claim PIP as they sent it to the wrong address so it was after his DLA stopped that he rang to claim. So it must be this phone call they are talking about and stating that during this he didn't ask for his old DLA evidence to be used. Does any of this make a difference?
  • mikehughescqmikehughescq Posts: 2,205Member Brian Blessed
    There’s no way of knowing what difference it would make but having read that I would say ask for directions re: the PIP 1 abs explain why.
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    There’s no way of knowing what difference it would make but having read that I would say ask for directions re: the PIP 1 abs explain why.
    My brother has already highlighted to the tribunal that there is no evidence from DWP of being asked about DLA evidence (he didn't mention about not receiving the pip invitation). Should he still do as you have stated above?
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    keira said:
    There’s no way of knowing what difference it would make but having read that I would say ask for directions re: the PIP 1 abs explain why.
    My brother has already highlighted to the tribunal that there is no evidence from DWP of being asked about DLA evidence (he didn't mention about not receiving the pip invitation). Should he still do as you have stated above?

  • mikehughescqmikehughescq Posts: 2,205Member Brian Blessed
    Yes. It takes the decision as to whether to listen to the point out of the hands if the tribunal. 
  • keirakeira Posts: 102Member Talkative
    edited March 8
    Yes. It takes the decision as to whether to listen to the point out of the hands if the tribunal. 
    I'm sorry but I don't quite understand what you mean? Could you possibly elaborate?
  • mikehughescqmikehughescq Posts: 2,205Member Brian Blessed
    You don’t have the DLA evidence but you want it included. If you put that in a submission or turn up on the day and argue for an adjournment to get it then you run the risk the tribunal will simply ignore the request and carry on regardless. That may be a sign they think there’s an award or it may indicate a lack of understanding of the importance of the PIP 1. If you ask a judge in advance to direct that the DLA evidence is included as well as the PIP 1 then, if the judge agrees, the evidence goes into the papers and the tribunal on the day have to address it once you raise it.
Sign in or join us to comment.